Bargaining: Why Did you have to Leave?

Asking “why?” became my bargaining tool. I cannot count the times I asked that question.  I asked John in my letters to him. I asked God, but there was never a response.  The result was many days of creating reasons that made sense to me and creating scenarios that would make the outcome different.

Several years ago, I wrote a series of posts on grief after my husband died. It seems appropriate to share some of those earlier posts now, nearly seven years later. Grief impacts us daily and is never easy to manage. This post discusses the unanswered “why?” that surrounded John’s unexpected death.

“Why?” becomes a bargaining tool

John often sent texts that began with “Howzit?” He wanted to know how my day was going and that he was awake. I miss that phrase; I miss his simple words of care and humor that turned even the most difficult day into a pleasant one. I could not understand why God would take those moments of joy from me. I wondered how I would survive without him.

Asking “why?” became my bargaining tool. I cannot count the times I asked that question.  I asked John in my letters to him. I asked God, but there was never a response.  I spent many days creating reasons that made sense to me and thinking of scenarios that would make the outcome different. My list of “What if…” was long and complicated. I told myself that if I knew “why”, I would feel less guilty and could let go of the self-blame.

Learning to change my focus

With time, I accepted that I would never know why John was taken from me, but not without a long intense struggle. Moving on from bargaining required me to stop asking why.  Once I stopped asking why I recalled the things John taught me. I recalled the life he lived. I remembered things he shared with me that helped me heal and become the person that I am. I can’t change the events of the day John died, but I can change what I focus on.

John once told me that it is more important to focus on how God brings you out of a painful experience than to focus on the experience. Remembering this helped me stop asking why John left me and begin focusing on sharing how he affected my life and my family.

This is not your fault

I don’t know how many times I have told someone who is in the midst of grief, “this is not your fault.” You may “know” the truth of that statement, but you are now experiencing the guilt and blame more intensely than ever before. When you feel guilt or blame creep in, remember how your loved one impacted your life. Focusing on the life lived by your loved one can help you move beyond the exhausting task of bargaining to change the unchangeable events surrounding the loss of your loved one.

The disciples’ grief & the bargaining

I imagine that the disciples asked “Why?” many times during the days after the crucifixion. Even though Christ told them what was to come, the followers did not understand they only had a short time left with their beloved leader, much less that he would be back. For His friends and disciples, the grief was real. These men and women lost the greatest companion they had ever known.

The promise that he would come back or even the promise that he was going to prepare a place for them did not ease their grief. They were in pain. They were afraid. They probably asked the question “Why did He let this happen? “ What could I have done to prevent it?” Perhaps they wondered how they could minister to others when their grief was so intense. I wonder if like me they struggled with thoughts they must deny their intense pain so those who looked to them for guidance would not lose faith. I imagine that hearing someone quote what Christ told them at the last supper resulted in a mixture of anger confusion and doubt. After all, they walked with Christ every day.

They wanted to know “Why did He leave us?”

Christ knew exactly what His future would be. He also knew nothing his disciples said or did would change the outcome. However, the disciples did not immediately understand or accept His purpose would continue without Christ’s physical presence.

Christ provides a comforter

Christ rose from the dead and then ascended to heaven, which though altogether different from death, still left the disciples on their own. The disciples finally understood Christ’s purpose and began sharing their experiences with the world. Christ gave them His Spirit, the comforter, to empower them in this mission. They stopped asking why He had to leave and started sharing who he was.

As followers of Christ, we have that same Spirit within us, a comforter in our deepest grief.  While the answer to “Why?” may not always come, the Spirit can empower you to change your focus and move past bargaining to embracing all that your loved one added to your life and taught.

List ways your loved one impacted your life? How can you share those “gifts” with others? Share your comments below.

Author: Charlotte B. Thomason

I hold a Master of Science in Social Work from the University of Texas at Austin and a Master of Arts in Apologetics, Emphasis in Cultural Apologetics from Houston Baptist University. I also hold a Bachelor of Arts in Social Work from Graceland University. With over 30 years of experience in foster care and social work, I have a wealth of experience from which to draw as I offer guidance to women in their journey of healing. I have seen, both professionally and personally the devastation created by child abuse. My writing also reflects my personal journey to healing.

Leave a Reply